On Darcy’s proposal in Pride and Prejudice
Darcy’s unexpected (or not so unexpected) proposal and his subsequent explanatory letter following Elizabeth’s violent refusal represent the turning point of the novel. It is the story’s moment of truth: not only because the reader now discovers or has its doubts confirmed about Darcy’s feelings and true character, but also because it is the first instance when the protagonists face each other revealing their true selves. In addition, Darcy’s letter turns out to be revelatory in explaining the title, as even though Darcy was already obviously standing for the ‘Pride’, thanks to Elizabeth’s constant reflections on the subject, never before was Elizabeth’s prejudiced mind revealed better than in confronting the true nature of her rejected suitor’s behaviour and manners as derived from his written confession.
The proposal scene brings the two main characters, standing on opposite positions to face each other and speak their minds openly for the first time. If Elizabeth’s strong antipathy, fuelled by her recent discovery of his role in her sister’s being ignored by Bingley while in London and the long acknowledged injustice that she thought him responsible of towards Wickham was more than obvious to even the most distracted reader, guessing Darcy’s antithetical feelings required a more challenging level of lecture. Still, however thoroughly a reader would have considered the subtle hints dropped by the narrator, such as the enduring observation of the brightness of Lizzy’s eyes, they could have only lead him or her to the conclusion that Darcy was far from despising or ignoring the heroine or at most feeling interested and attracted to her. The violence of his passion, as it erupts during his proposal must have taken by surprise even the keenest reader, as the narrator never bothered to thoroughly prepare the ground for this scene, whose unexpectedness induces the looked-for effect of surprise and dismay.
The result of this open exposure to the ‘other’s side of the story’ induces a deep feeling of humiliation in both protagonists and enables them to further analyse themselves and their conduct. It is indeed the point of departure for further change in the characters themselves, as they both gradually realise their own faults and start thinking of each other in a new light. It has been amply argued that this transformation is less obvious in Darcy than in Elizabeth. But nothing can be more natural than that, considering that after all the main character is the heroine and that the story is told entirely from her perspective to such an extent that the reader has no easy time to differentiate –if possible at all!- between the narrator’s voice and Lizzy’s own judgements in many a scene. This suddenly triggered but gradually appropriated metamorphosis in the characters is essential to the plot, as it finally enables in Elizabeth those feelings that will lead her to rise only a faint objection to visiting Pemberley, a place we now understand she almost yearns to see.
In fact, nowhere else in Austen’s novels does the relation between the two main characters shift so dramatically and stun the reader to such an extent as in Pride and Prejudice. Although deceived love like that of Marianne Dashwood’s for Willoughby in Sense and Sensibility or that of Edmund Bertram’s for Mary Crawford in Mansfield Park is not that uncommon, long steady affection like that between Fanny Price and Edmund Bertram, Elinor Dashwood and Edward Ferrars or Emma Woodhouse and Mr. Knightley seem to be the perfect recipe for a happy romance. Consequently, Darcy and Lizzy’s love story seems only all the more passionate, romantic and appealing not only to Austen’s contemporaries but even to uncountable subsequent generations of readers, marking it not only as her greatest masterpiece, but also as one of the most enduringly popular novels in the English language.





